The Gap Between Policy and Practice: Lessons from the Mid-term Evaluation of the 5th National Human Rights Plan (2023–2027)
Keywords:
National Human Rights Plan, Performance Evaluation, Mid-Term AssessmentAbstract
This research article aimed to (1) evaluate the mid-term performance of the 5th National Human Rights Plan (2023-2027) covering the period 2023-2024, (2) analyze its problems and obstacles in implementation, and (3) formulate policy recommendations for driving the plan in the second half. This qualitative research involved 427 key informants. Data were collected from the performance reports of 39 government agencies, four focus group discussions, and an academic conference. The analysis encompassed 148 indicators, comprising 56 indicators across five thematic areas and 92 indicators across 11 target groups. A color-coded rating system was employed to assess and classify the results.
The research findings revealed that (1) in terms of performance evaluation, 29.73% of the indicators under the 5th National Human Rights Plan were fully achieved, 21.62% were partially achieved, 28.38% were at risk of not being achieved, 3.38% were not achieved, and 16.89% could not be evaluated. Indicators under the target group plans demonstrated a higher achievement rate (40.22%) than those under the thematic plans (12.50%). The highest achievement rate was observed among victims within the justice system (71.43%). (2) The major challenges and obstacles included incomplete data reporting, unclear and outdated indicators, budgetary constraints, and insufficient structural support mechanisms. (3) The policy recommendations included allocating dedicated budgets, developing a centralized database, revising and updating performance indicators, and establishing an independent oversight mechanism.
